Saturday, May 19, 2012   
  Search   
 
Register  Login  
Home  
some questions for you INTJ's
Last Post 19 May 2012 01:54 AM by J Squirrel. 70 Replies.
'; AddThis - Bookmarking and Sharing Button Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 2 of 4 << < 1234 > >>
Author Messages
PurpleGiraffe User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 28/F
Relationship: Jirafa sola
IM:
Philosopher of ENFPs
Philosopher of ENFPs
Posts:962
Avatar

--
18 Jan 2012 12:00 AM  
If it helps, DelphianEtude, I have found that the best way/s to develop Fi is/are just to walk into the uncomfortable zone and just keep returning to it often because those areas that make you feel nervous to think about are often indicative of the things that affect you emotionally. Does it make you nervous to think about helping Betsy or trying to make a new friend even if you might be rejected? Then do that. And repeat. It is scary, but it should teach you a thing or two.

On a different note, I don't necessarily agree that feelings aren't all that important to INTJs. I think it is often just that they aren't understood and it is difficult to make rational decisions off of something unknown. I find that often in more mature INTJs, one can often find that an INTJ will use Ni/Te to support the desires of Fi rather than fighting it or trying to hide its existence. Feelings and logic aren't one and the same in an INTJ, but rather they often are two different spheres existing side-by-side and often the way to get the most objective outcome is to understand and incorporate both into the process.
DelphianEtude User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 29
Relationship:
IM:
I Just Joined
I Just Joined
Posts:17
Avatar

--
19 Jan 2012 08:21 PM  
Funny how this fictitious Betsy character has become an important person in this thread. I think you touched on something there though PurpleGiraffe. Helping people without some kind of goal or reward does make me feel uncomfortable for many different reasons. Making decisions based on feelings is probably the most uncomfortable thing I can do. I need to study people who have built successful careers off of this sort of thing. Maybe do some local volunteer work or something and sort of ease my way into a discomfort zone where even if I make bad feelings-based decisions, the consequences won't be dire. Rejection makes me feel a lot better than uncertainty.

I think the problem is that my Ni and Ti sort of guide me in this misleading direction that letting Fi into the equation is just going to complicate and destroy an outcome that would otherwise be beneficial and certain. They don't cooperate, but poorly compensate for my immature Fi. I have a feeling that coming to terms with this is going to be a lifelong struggle for me.
Moxie User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 3x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Posts:35
Avatar

--
19 Jan 2012 08:54 PM  
LOL. see how good us ENFP's are in setting the conversational direction? We saw the underlying feeling question behind Betsy and honed in on it. Betsy is somewhat of an allegory for how INTJ's operate, thus the interest.
Stripes User is Offline
MBTI: intj
Age/Sex: M
Relationship:
IM:
Senior Editor
Senior Editor
Posts:404
Avatar

--
19 Jan 2012 11:36 PM  
See Moxie, I knew you were crafty:p
When all else fails, improvise!
InvisibleJim User is Offline
MBTI: ILI
Age/Sex: 26
Relationship: ENFP
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:85
Avatar

--
21 Jan 2012 08:27 PM  

1) Why? I've never met an intj who didn't know exactly why they did a certain action - so why are you guys here?

People who self type themselves INTJ are typically either INTJ or ISTJ with a smattering of IxTPs to boot.  People who self type themselves as ENFP are typically either ENFP or ESFP with a smattering of ExFJs to boot - There are some good reasons for this, but either way they are typing behaviourally rather than cognitively.

People who have diametrically opposed behavioural styles get a lot of high value interaction from their opposites.  There is a lot to learn so there is a lot of low lying fruit from even the most trivial interactions.

2) what exactly are you guys "intuitive" about? do you intuit other's emotions like we (enfp) do?

This viewpoint is a 'scratched surface' interpretation.  The IJ group are all strategistically focused and are into moving the position of the problem to solve it.  The INTJ group by contrast is particularly focused on playing with the consequences of ideas and how they evolve through time to a point at which this is as natural as 'intuiting emotions'.

Again a simplification, but hopefully it offers some understanding.

3) how emotionally aware are you really? i suspect that it's more than you let on - all the intj's i know are secret sentimentalists.

Very, but we tend to be emotionally closed.  I don't intrinsically believe that any extrovert or introvert is more emotionally aware/empathic, for which I have a few reasons.  The INTJ being reserved and concise is quite observant of their environment.  There are some underlying reasons for this including a hyper-sensitivity to sensory information changes that is a consequence of opposition to the method of 'intuiting' as above.

4) would you agree that interfacing with an enfp attracts you because we are like a sort of puzzle to you?

Not really, the ENFP I'm seeing, much like my ENFP exes in the past attracts me because they help me to forget my own puzzles and relax.

As an ENFP friend says to me: You guys really just like having us around.

The opposite is reported to be true, i.e. the ENFP seems to consider the INTJ an attractive puzzle.

5) is it true that if an intj let's you get close that you need not talk too much about it, because "geez, i let you in that should be proof enough that i enjoy you"

Conciseness is close to godliness: Yes.

 

InvisibleJim User is Offline
MBTI: ILI
Age/Sex: 26
Relationship: ENFP
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:85
Avatar

--
21 Jan 2012 08:32 PM  
@DelphineanEtude -" I don't want to say that I don't care about other people's feelings, but they are usually near the bottom on my list of importance. I act like I care through routine, forced small-talk maneuvers I've developed over the years" I'm curious about this statement - doesn't this make you lonely sometimes? why are the feelings of others near the bottom? does this hold true in your relationships as well?
This question is simpler than it looks:
If you have a fundamental belief that everyone is the master of their own destiny you know it is irrelvant to attempt to manage other peoples emotional responses.  If you can manage your own this is to your benefit.  However if your emotional responses are in sync then you have synergy.  An artificially managed responses which you manipulate someone into having has no value.
In relationships this can be even more important.  You express how you are feeling and expect a counter reaction to that which is honest and direct.
Loneliness is not really a problem because there is always something important to do.

 

InvisibleJim User is Offline
MBTI: ILI
Age/Sex: 26
Relationship: ENFP
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:85
Avatar

--
21 Jan 2012 08:35 PM  
Posted By Moxie on 16 Jan 2012 04:47 PM
 would you say that Fi is your most dominant "non-dominant" function? what strategies do you use to develop it?
Development is a falsitude in cognitive functioning.  When one looks into the self and drops external expectations and allows a natural balance to be reached then you see natural preferences emerge.  Cognitive functions are not muscles!

 

InvisibleJim User is Offline
MBTI: ILI
Age/Sex: 26
Relationship: ENFP
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:85
Avatar

--
21 Jan 2012 08:37 PM  
Posted By Moxie on 19 Jan 2012 07:54 PM
LOL. see how good us ENFP's are in setting the conversational direction? We saw the underlying feeling question behind Betsy and honed in on it. Betsy is somewhat of an allegory for how INTJ's operate, thus the interest.
There is a reason Lenore describes ENFPs as activators and INTJs as chart the course type individuals.
The ENFP says 'I want to go to Italy' the INTJ checks the compass and sets the direction to Italy.

 

Moxie User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 3x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Posts:35
Avatar

--
22 Jan 2012 02:05 AM  
Invisible Jim is a Smarty McSmarty pants.

seriously good answers, albeit a bit didactic and textbook and quintessentially INTJ responses.

hmmm- i think cognitive functions can be expressed and worked upon much like a muscle. if one doesn't realize that self reflection is a necessary cognitive function or order to more deeply develop i think it must be learned (read: realized, actualized etc. as opposed to "taught") and consciously observed and my INTJ friends are in actually the ones who explained this process to me - that as they matured (they are all over 40 now) that they realized that they needed the tools afforded in the development of (in particular) their Fi functioning in order to get more out of life as they got older.

hmmmm again, i've also had more than a few INTJ's tell me that we are a puzzle - not as in a logical puzzle. maybe "puzzling" would be a more appropriate term. what i've been told is that they fundamentally rarely operate from a foundation of "feeling" and it's very naturally foreign for them to be able to place themselves in that space given that feeling is not something logically commanded. this is particularly true for those who score high on the T/J aspect.

and hell yes, i totally agree, i love having INTJ's around. you guys are a puzzle to us. for being only 1% of the population, i sure have a lot of truly INTJ friends. i think the N really resonates between us, which usually tells me if the person is an
"S" as opposed to an N - my highest score by far is N - far higher than the others. I can generally intuit that connection

mostly i just have a good time communicating with you guys. there's a lot that doesn't need explanation, but we enjoy making you explain it anyways. and you make us think more logically. good times.
Moxie User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 3x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Posts:35
Avatar

--
22 Jan 2012 02:19 AM  
On Getting to Italy -


ENFP: "Let's HITCHHIKE there!!"
INTJ: rolls eyes, continues researching the most expedient way of reaching destination

Once in Italy:

ENFP: Sets up surprise treasure hunt in the Duomo for the INTJ, tells him as they are entering the building.
INTJ: secretly LOVES the attention given to him by this somewhat oddly exuberant, friendly, yet strangely detached human being
ENFP: "how do we change this money over? and who is your favorite renaissance figure and why? Let's rent scooters and go explore some non tourist areas!"
INTJ: proceeds to explain all his research into the matter, honestly explains who and why. agrees to scooter rental, researches where to rent scooters (of course the ENFP didn't think that far in advance) because there's usually something interesting that happens when she wants to go on adventure, and she's one of the few who can get him to do it.
ENFP: genuinely interested in his explanation and reasons behind his choice of historical figure, offers her own.

Day in the life of.

right?


incrediblemind User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 46
Relationship: stuck with a sensor :(
IM:
Advanced Member
Advanced Member
Posts:216
Avatar

--
22 Jan 2012 02:54 AM  
Posted By Moxie on 22 Jan 2012 01:19 AM

right?

Haha, yeah sort of.. 

Muse User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 22/Male
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just joined
I just joined
Posts:7
Avatar

--
02 Feb 2012 10:49 PM  

 Hi.

1) To talk to ENFPs. Maybe make some friends.

2) I have heard that INTJs are very good at empathy when they care about someone else. Personally I know that I am very careful about upsetting the people I care about because I can easily imagine what something might make them feel like. As a result it is very very rare that someone important to me is mad or sad because of me. Im not sure if that is intuition or emotional inteligence with extroverted thinking though. 

3) as far as awareness goes, sure I know what I am feeling when I feel it; even the more confusing emotions I can sum up. But much of my day I spend interacting with people that I do not engage with emotionally. So most of my day is spent not really feeling many emotions.

4) No. I just find the interaction to be enjoyable, and I dont find ENFPs (or any type) to be hard to understand.

5) This question seems to be asking and implying a few different things. If I let someone get close I dont mind them needing confirmation of our closeness.. "Would you say we are close?" "..Ya, I would say so."

but the "geez, i let you in that should be proof enough that i enjoy you" brings to mind two possibly negative things.

1. The ENFP might be lacking confidence in the mutual closeness of the relationship despite that closeness being shown or expressed.

2. The INTJ might not be conveying/reciprocating the closeness or confirmation of it in a way that the other party can recieve.

Both of these are simple communication issues, but should really be addressed. 

Psyko User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: Thirtysomething - Female
Relationship: Happily married to ENFP of my dreams :)
IM:
ENFP Muse & Addict

Abnormal Situation Manager
Moderator: NTs
Moderator: NTs
Posts:677
Avatar

--

05 Apr 2012 08:16 AM  
Hi Moxie and welcome as a new and shiny exciting member on this forum, I was going to answer your questions weeks ago but got sidetracked.

1. Originally I had burned myself on 2-3 ENFP guys that were not serious about me and they ended up hurting my feelings quite a bit. I still knew that that the ENFP type was impossible for me to stay away from, so I joined the forum to get some answers to my questions about ENFP behavior and also maybe to get a tip or two on how to attract one for good. (Which I did, yay!)

2. We're intuitive about intentions and the future. We can see far into the future and foresee the outcome of events. I also know about a person's intentions before they know it themselves. You guys are good at that too, but more tightly connected to other people's emotions.

3. Very emotionally aware but we hide it and we do not want people to see our emotions. We've learned to keep a poker face. We're not necessarily in tune with our feelings though and can dismiss them if they seem 'silly' to us. I cry at movies all the time and I don't care who sees me cry, it's the one place I don't care if I'm a sap...

4. No you're not a puzzle to us I think. We are attracted to you because you're fun and smart and make us feel good. And it's very attractive to us that we're on the same wave length. You get us where so few do!!

5. Not really, if I'm close with someone I open up and talk all the time (but maybe it is different because I'm a woman.) We're not willing to talk so much about how close we feel though if that is what you mean. If you're in, you'll see us be comfortable around you and we'll open up to you. Do not betray our trust by talking to others about our secrets and reserve some secrets on your end just for us if you want us to truly feel special. I have been upset many times because I was made to feel special by an ENFP who told me something 'in confidence' and then I see them say the same thing to a random person just 10 minutes later... That is a big faux pas with INTJs! We feel that you're shallow when you do that and not special to you any more.
CherryBomb User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: Female
Relationship: happy w/ INTJ
IM:
Posts:2
Avatar

--
18 Apr 2012 04:45 PM  

  First Hi Everyone!

 Im new to this forum and I stumbled across this thread while looking for more information on my MBTI (ENFP) and my long time boyfriends MBTI (INTJ) and their compatibility. So far Ive read that we are supposed to be highly compatible. My hope is that an INTJ might be able to help me figure out more on how to better work with my INTJ...thats not to say we dont work well now but at times it would be nice to get some insight on how to better incorporate his personality into our daily lives...seeing as how he generally just allows me to do as i want and goes behind me to ensure that im not causing trouble or forgetting something . I would like to know about something that INTJ's like to do? Something that draws on his INTJ personality? He loves puzzels and strategies but i can hardly sit through with him. I dont know im just putting the question out there...what is something that you all like to do? =)

Why do I have to 'put my two cents in'... when it's only a 'penny for your thoughts'? Where's that extra penny going to?
incrediblemind User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 46
Relationship: stuck with a sensor :(
IM:
Advanced Member
Advanced Member
Posts:216
Avatar

--
18 Apr 2012 05:50 PM  
Posted By CherryBomb on 18 Apr 2012 03:45 PM

 My hope is that an INTJ might be able to help me figure out more on how to better work with my INTJ...

By all means enquire here, but you will get an overwhelming response from http://intjforum.com/

 

ENFPGuy User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP-Type 7
Age/Sex: M/30/Europe (from Dallas)
Relationship: Married to awesome INTJ
IM: Lordxred - (aol)

ENFP Tribe Leader

Super Admin

sbalbom
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:438
Avatar

--

19 Apr 2012 03:40 PM  
incrediblemind, I appreciate it if you didn't promote other forums here.

Thanks
------------------

Whatever is done for love always occurs beyond good and evil.

incrediblemind User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 46
Relationship: stuck with a sensor :(
IM:
Advanced Member
Advanced Member
Posts:216
Avatar

--
19 Apr 2012 04:42 PM  
I make no apologies for my INTJish response. The person asks a specific question and is afforded a specific answer that will connect them with the most authoritative source on the planet. However, If there was a private message system available I would have used it.
PurpleGiraffe User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 28/F
Relationship: Jirafa sola
IM:
Philosopher of ENFPs
Philosopher of ENFPs
Posts:962
Avatar

--
19 Apr 2012 10:40 PM  
Fair enough, but is there really one "most authoritative" source for INTJs, Incrediblemind? This forum is teeming with our kind. Besides, you wouldn't frequent Pizza Hut and then when someone walks in and asks you what pizza is good you tell them Dominoes next door has the best veggie pizza. Well, you might, but it would seem silly not to realize why the Pizza Hut owner wouldn't particularly like this, no?
CherryBomb User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: Female
Relationship: happy w/ INTJ
IM:
Posts:2
Avatar

--
20 Apr 2012 12:34 AM  

 Sorry i wasnt trying to create any problems...but once again i would appreciate any answer i wasnt just trying to talk to INTJ's but also to inquire about ENFP-INTJ relations and expeirience from other ENFP's who might have more insight  =X

Why do I have to 'put my two cents in'... when it's only a 'penny for your thoughts'? Where's that extra penny going to?
incrediblemind User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 46
Relationship: stuck with a sensor :(
IM:
Advanced Member
Advanced Member
Posts:216
Avatar

--
20 Apr 2012 04:30 AM  
Posted By PurpleGiraffe on 19 Apr 2012 09:40 PM
Fair enough, but is there really one "most authoritative" source for INTJs, Incrediblemind? This forum is teeming with our kind. Besides, you wouldn't frequent Pizza Hut and then when someone walks in and asks you what pizza is good you tell them Dominoes next door has the best veggie pizza. Well, you might, but it would seem silly not to realize why the Pizza Hut owner wouldn't particularly like this, no?


There is no one authorative source for any 'thing'.  The Internet and indeed society is a place of mulitple truths - the more we collect, the more we are able to form our own opinion - it's about being enabled.

I make no "promotion" of it.  It is a reference, and members will use as they see fit, or not.

Irritatingly, INTJ do not utter random facts(sic) just to irritate - they only speak to concisely address the issue.  People will use as they see fit, and no malice is ever intended.  Search yourself and you will know this.  Even ENFPGuys' signature states it.

If feelings were hurt then I apologise, but I do not retract.

 

You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 2 of 4 << < 1234 > >>


Active Forums 4.1
Find: ENFP Relationships, ENFP career advice and MBTI Chat. ENFP and INTJ, ENFP and INFJ, ENFP and INFP, ENFP and ESTP, ENFP and ESFP, ENFP and ISFP, ENFP and ISTP, ENFP and ISTJ Informaiton. enfp personality briggs careers meyers intj type infp relationships compatibility infj profile enfps career famous jobs love test entp intp forum match.

Downloaded from DNNSkins.com