Monday, May 21, 2012   
  Search   
 
Register  Login  
Home  
Gender Roles: Why Do Most People Care?
Last Post 29 Oct 2011 10:00 AM by Sharon Vineyard. 32 Replies.
'; AddThis - Bookmarking and Sharing Button Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 212 > >>
Author Messages
Sharon Vineyard User is Offline
MBTI: INTP
Age/Sex: Gender Neutral
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:83
Avatar

--
26 Oct 2011 08:40 AM  

 I have made a thread a while back dealing with feelings for another. I am over that or at least the worst of it. I have soulsearched quite a bit over the past few weeks and I have come to the conclusion that I really want someone that can accept me for who I am. I on the other hand feel that I am a fairly good person and am able to accept myself now (though before I was struggling). The one thing that most people can't seem to get past about me is my attitude towards "gender roles." I consider myself gender neutral where I really can't relate to either but rather I feel I am in a sense both. Most people (even my closest friends) find this to an extent unaccepting and I fail to see why does society overall care so much? You see T.V shows for example and the media showing us how its "supposed" to be. Even when women have jobs, pay tends to be lower which in this economy may make even the working woman end up as a housewife after she marries. I know its impossible to convince society and my friends to think the way I do but I really wish I knew why do people buy into it? 

Nadette User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 2x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Beloved Author
Beloved Author
Posts:680
Avatar

--
26 Oct 2011 10:16 AM  

I completely agree and relate. Gender roles are limiting and untrue constructions. People like them because breaking from tradition is scary and it's a good deal if you are a man.

alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

26 Oct 2011 04:52 PM  
Thousands of years of being property vs a few generations of equality....and that's only in a portion of the world. Be thankful that a few lingering gender roles are all that remain in the first world. It's not as though you'll get stoned for not accepting your "place" as a woman. And gender roles are just as stereotypical for guys. It's not fair, but it's not impossible to step out of the roles into your own identity. Unless you're in a creepy, cult-like Stepford Wives type community.... There's a culture for even the weirdest people....and the internet opens up even more obscure groups. >.> And let's face it, feminism is a *terrible* idea if carried through to it's conclusion. Until men start giving birth, there's a necessity for some special treatment of women in the workplace....including the guarantee that your job will still be there after maternity leave.
Nadette User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 2x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Beloved Author
Beloved Author
Posts:680
Avatar

--
26 Oct 2011 08:25 PM  
Men should get maternity leave too.
Stripes User is Offline
MBTI: intj
Age/Sex: M
Relationship:
IM:
Senior Editor
Senior Editor
Posts:404
Avatar

--
27 Oct 2011 11:11 AM  

 And women still wonder where all the good men have gone

When all else fails, improvise!
PurpleGiraffe User is Offline
MBTI: INTJ
Age/Sex: 28/F
Relationship: Jirafa sola
IM:
Philosopher of ENFPs
Philosopher of ENFPs
Posts:964
Avatar

--
27 Oct 2011 12:40 PM  
^^ They were eaten by the PUA gods.
Nadette User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 2x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Beloved Author
Beloved Author
Posts:680
Avatar

--
27 Oct 2011 01:02 PM  
Stripes, if you are indicating with your comment that women don't act/believe correctly either, then you are right. We all still need to work on not being gender neutral in our roles and expectations. Extreme feminists are just as much off the mark as extreme masculinists. Thankfully, Alysaria is also correct in pointing out that we have come a long way! That doesn't mean that we should slack in our awareness of our own perceptions, the perceptions of others, and the effects that these perceptions have on limiting individuals in our society, including ourselves. I am truly idealistic enough to think that there should be equal opportunities, equal benefits, and equally tabula rosa expectations for both sexes.
alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

27 Oct 2011 07:17 PM  
I'm going to assume you mean paternity leave lol. And guys *do* take paternity leave if they are the primary caregiver....however, there is still the necessity of birthing the child. And even if the mother only spends the required couple of days at the hospital and intends to return straight to work, she still needs those couple of days to give birth. Not to mention the breaks required to pump the excess milk.... >.>

>< and tabula rasa means blank slate....and refers specifically to the belief that children are born as empty vessels upon which you create an identity as a parent.

There's nothing wrong with wanting everyone to have equal opportunities and benefits....but unfortunately, you're going to find some groups like those perks too much to give them up without a screaming fight of sexism, racism, or whatever other "ism" they attach to it.
alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

27 Oct 2011 07:40 PM  
And before I hear anything about it....yes, certain benefits were/are necessary and served a just purpose....but eventually, they need to outlive their purpose. Especially when it's the group clinging to them that is keeping the "isms" alive more than anyone else.
Nadette User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex: 2x/F
Relationship:
IM:
Beloved Author
Beloved Author
Posts:680
Avatar

--
27 Oct 2011 09:17 PM  
Sometimes tabula rosa just means blank slate. It doesn't have to specifically refer to children being born as empty vessels. I meant that society should keep a blank slate in their expectations concerning gender. And, I guess I did mean paternity leave... does it matter? I just wanted to emphasize that men and women should be treated equal. Every benefit we desire for women should also be desired for men. In this specific case, I think that both parents should be able to take some time off to adjust to the new life in the family. Idealistic? Perhaps.
alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 12:20 PM  

You can check it out for yourself. The disambiguation are all episodes of tv shows or the names of soundtracks.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tabula_rasa

Tabula rasa is the epistemological theory that individuals are born without built-in mental content and that their knowledge comes from experience and perception. Generally proponents of the tabula rasa thesis favour the "nurture" side of the nature versus nurture debate, when it comes to aspects of one's personality, social and emotional behaviour, and intelligence. The term in Latin equates to the English "blank slate" (or more accurately, "erased slate") (which refers to writing on a slate sheet in chalk) but comes from the Roman tabula or wax tablet, used for notes, which was blanked by heating the wax and then smoothing it to give a tabula rasa.



You can't expect people to keep that empty context (unless they have severe mental handicaps). We're all walking around with Implicit Association, that is, an immediate, unconscious reaction to everything we observe....especially people. https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/research/ <---this is a pretty interesting set of tests that harvard puts out to research implicit association. Having experience with a certain group can cause certain biases....but having no interaction with said group can create just as many biases. For example, a person who has never interacted with little children before and has no preconceptions may still be alarmed and react negatively upon first seeing a group of hyperactive rugrats running around screaming their heads off.

But back to gender....because you *really* have to be sheltered to have no knowledge or interaction with the opposite sex. Let's put this into a different perspective here. Two people apply for a job...I'll put pictures below to emphasize. Neither has any experience in the field they are applying for (beyond necessary college courses), but they are the only applicants. Both are physically fit and equally intelligent and capable.

1. The job is in a doctor's clinic and primarily deals with giving prostate exams
2. The job is a bridal shop helping women try on dresses

Is it sexist if the woman doesn't get the clinic job? Is it sexist if the man doesn't get the bridal shop job? Is it sexist for a bride to not want a male employee to help her in the fitting room? Is it sexist for a man to be uncomfortable with a woman performing a prostate exam on him? If the woman was pregnant, would it be sexist for her to be denied to volunteer at a cat shelter? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis#Pregnancy_precautions)

Sharon Vineyard User is Offline
MBTI: INTP
Age/Sex: Gender Neutral
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:83
Avatar

--
28 Oct 2011 12:34 PM  
I love the discussion going on here ^^ but my question hasn't been answered or at least not in the way I was hoping. Perhaps this is no answer and it depends on individual? :/ What I got out of this so far is basically... I just deal with the issue that they won't completely accept my gender neutrality and leave it at that and get on with my life?
alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 12:35 PM  
I'm trying to make the point that sexism and inequality aren't the same thing, and inequality isn't always bad. Having the ability to do the same thing as someone of the opposite gender does not make it prudent.
Sharon Vineyard User is Offline
MBTI: INTP
Age/Sex: Gender Neutral
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:83
Avatar

--
28 Oct 2011 12:38 PM  
Posted By alysaria on 28 Oct 2011 11:35 AM
I'm trying to make the point that sexism and inequality aren't the same thing, and inequality isn't always bad. Having the ability to do the same thing as someone of the opposite gender does not make it prudent.


I never said it was a "bad" thing. I can try and live with it. Though I am not really talking about the topic in a "broad" sense, I just brought that up to demonstrate an example that relates to what I am going through without getting too personal since I am not big on sharing a real example of what I experienced. Now in terms of the ones I consider "friends" who do not "accept" me for being gender neutral, do I just deal with that? :/

alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 12:41 PM  

The media's only purpose is to make money, Sharon. They don't care one way or the other how someone is portrayed as long as it's marketable....and it's safer to go with what's worked before. Most networks don't take risks.

Also: http://www.time.com/time/business/a...74,00.html

alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 12:43 PM  
Now in terms of the ones I consider "friends" who do not "accept" me for being gender neutral, do I just deal with that? :/


I guess I don't understand how it is they aren't accepting you. Do they tell you to be more girly or something?
Sharon Vineyard User is Offline
MBTI: INTP
Age/Sex: Gender Neutral
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:83
Avatar

--
28 Oct 2011 12:43 PM  
Posted By alysaria on 28 Oct 2011 11:41 AM

The media's only purpose is to make money, Sharon. They don't care one way or the other how someone is portrayed as long as it's marketable....and it's safer to go with what's worked before. Most networks don't take risks.

Also: http://www.time.com/time/business/a...74,00.html


I take that as a yes to my question, thanks. 

alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 12:44 PM  
We seem to be posting at the same time, which is making this a bit confusing. ><
Sharon Vineyard User is Offline
MBTI: INTP
Age/Sex: Gender Neutral
Relationship: Single
IM:
I just Joined
I just Joined
Posts:83
Avatar

--
28 Oct 2011 12:48 PM  
Posted By alysaria on 28 Oct 2011 11:43 AM
Now in terms of the ones I consider "friends" who do not "accept" me for being gender neutral, do I just deal with that? :/


I guess I don't understand how it is they aren't accepting you. Do they tell you to be more girly or something?


As I said, I don't want to share personal examples. As for the "confusion" I don't get really but also why I brought up the PM idea since that would be a bit conveniant (a bit off topic). Just say that you spend years getting to know someone since childhood and then when you hit puberty and you notice that you can't relate to the "norm" or to anyone, the one you knew treats you differently because no matter what you can't just "change" yourself nor see a reason to and the same for them where you don't wish for them to "change" but you just long to be accepted again...

alysaria User is Offline
MBTI: ENFP
Age/Sex:
Relationship:
IM:
Empress of Random

Founding Member
Administrator
Administrator
Posts:2938
Avatar

--

28 Oct 2011 01:10 PM  
Yea...PMs would definitely help. The confusion is just that I'd finish typing a post only to find that you'd replied to my first post and hadn't seen my second post, so I'd be replying to your previous post after you already replied to my previous post. >.>

I kind of get it... I'm guessing this is someone you really care about and it bothers you that you can't relate to them the same way you used to? Regardless of gender identity, this happens about that time. Middle school is that awkward stage where everyone is trying to figure out who they are. Even the ones that seem sure are not. People flock to groups that represent them....and the members adapt to each other to form a single identity....and you get a clique. Sometimes childhood friends just don't fit into the same clique.... My childhood best friend ended up being one of the popular "bad" girls; she smoked, she slept around, and she had a baby at 16. I was not part of that clique, even though she really wanted me to still relate to her and tried to drag me in a few times. It just didn't work out anymore. We stayed friends, but not really close friends.
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 1 of 212 > >>


Active Forums 4.1
Find: ENFP Relationships, ENFP career advice and MBTI Chat. ENFP and INTJ, ENFP and INFJ, ENFP and INFP, ENFP and ESTP, ENFP and ESFP, ENFP and ISFP, ENFP and ISTP, ENFP and ISTJ Informaiton. enfp personality briggs careers meyers intj type infp relationships compatibility infj profile enfps career famous jobs love test entp intp forum match.

Downloaded from DNNSkins.com